Technology Resonance

The sociologist Hartmut Rosa develops with his resonance theory a concept that describes how people can build a vibrant, responsive relationship with the world - with fellow humans, nature, work, or cultural practices. Resonance arises in moments of mutual touch: When we let ourselves be addressed by something and at the same time enter into a relationship ourselves. In such experiences, a transformation occurs - a 'world transformation' - in which both the subject and the world change.

The smartphone is probably one of the digital devices whose world transformation most have experienced.

In contrast, there is alienation. It describes a state of lack of relationship, where the world appears mute and inaccessible to the subject. According to Rosa, modern society is characterized by a logic of acceleration and 'dynamic stabilization,' which is geared towards constant increase - more options, more reach, more efficiency. This logic is reflected in the so-called 'Triple-A Approach': Everything should be available (Available), accessible (Accessible), and attainable (Attainable).

Digitization radicalizes this dynamic by promising seemingly unlimited access to knowledge, social contacts, and cultural goods. However, mere availability does not create resonance. On the contrary: When technological means transform cultural practices - such as learning an instrument, having a conversation, or experiencing art - primarily under the aspect of making them available and increasing efficiency, the loss of resonant experiences threatens.

Brankele Frank recently expressed on Dutch TV what is meant by resonant experiences. Neuroscientific findings confirm her suspicion. Those who learn a musical instrument experience not only effort, deprivation, sweat, and tears, but primarily joy, self-efficacy. Attention, self-control, emotion regulation, and better cognitive properties develop. Also, the dominances that can be measured in the brain. We will revisit this in the chapter on shortcut technologies.

In any case. Technology shifts the focus from deep, transformative engagement with reality to mere consumability or quick goal achievement. This can lead to alienation from the practice itself. Technology not only becomes a tool but increasingly shapes our identity and our daily perception of the world.